{"reviewedAt":"2026-10-15","scope":"Independent named-place reference points, not farm coordinates or polygon-derived centroids.","points":[{"id":"indonesia-133","regionId":"indonesia-133","oldCoordinates":[98.85,2.15],"proposedCoordinates":[98.866,2.276],"geonamesId":"1214641","description":"Named Lintongnihuta settlement/seat in Humbang Hasundutan, within the exact Lintong Nihuta district.","evidenceIds":["lintong-bps","indonesia-gi"],"status":"proposed-for-parent-review","coordinateSource":"https://www.geonames.org/1214641/","license":"CC BY 4.0","licenseUrl":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","attribution":"GeoNames","notDerivedFromBoundary":true,"gazetteerName":"Lintongnihuta","featureCode":"P.PPLA3","countryCode":"ID","recordModified":"2022-12-30","dumpUrl":"https://download.geonames.org/export/dump/ID.zip","dumpSha256":"b5b4b38f77fc090b4fdd49e71c0d51567f91426fce4ed746e1401c7bfc7b982c","before":[98.85,2.15],"after":[98.866,2.276],"scope":"Named Lintongnihuta settlement/seat in Humbang Hasundutan, within the exact Lintong Nihuta district. Independent named reference; not a surveyed farm coordinate.","method":"Published named point; no polygon-derived centroid or nearest-border snap."},{"id":"indonesia-134","regionId":"indonesia-134","oldCoordinates":[99.25,0.73],"proposedCoordinates":[99.70908,0.66758],"geonamesId":"1215041","description":"Kotanopan town reference within one of the six officially listed Mandailing GI districts. The town is not asserted to be a coffee farm or the whole Mandailing region.","evidenceIds":["indonesia-gi"],"status":"proposed-for-parent-review","coordinateSource":"https://www.geonames.org/1215041/","license":"CC BY 4.0","licenseUrl":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","attribution":"GeoNames","notDerivedFromBoundary":true,"gazetteerName":"Kotanopan","featureCode":"P.PPLA3","countryCode":"ID","recordModified":"2022-12-30","dumpUrl":"https://download.geonames.org/export/dump/ID.zip","dumpSha256":"b5b4b38f77fc090b4fdd49e71c0d51567f91426fce4ed746e1401c7bfc7b982c","before":[99.25,0.73],"after":[99.70908,0.66758],"scope":"Kotanopan town reference within one of the six officially listed Mandailing GI districts. The town is not asserted to be a coffee farm or the whole Mandailing region. Independent named reference; not a surveyed farm coordinate.","method":"Published named point; no polygon-derived centroid or nearest-border snap."},{"id":"indonesia-136","regionId":"indonesia-136","oldCoordinates":[121.09,-8.56],"proposedCoordinates":[120.9744,-8.7848],"geonamesId":"1650720","description":"Named Bajawa town, Ngada seat, within Bajawa subdistrict; not the different same-name settlement in Ende.","evidenceIds":["bajawa-bps","indonesia-gi"],"status":"proposed-for-parent-review","coordinateSource":"https://www.geonames.org/1650720/","license":"CC BY 4.0","licenseUrl":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","attribution":"GeoNames","notDerivedFromBoundary":true,"gazetteerName":"Bajawa","featureCode":"P.PPLA2","countryCode":"ID","recordModified":"2022-12-31","dumpUrl":"https://download.geonames.org/export/dump/ID.zip","dumpSha256":"b5b4b38f77fc090b4fdd49e71c0d51567f91426fce4ed746e1401c7bfc7b982c","before":[121.09,-8.56],"after":[120.9744,-8.7848],"scope":"Named Bajawa town, Ngada seat, within Bajawa subdistrict; not the different same-name settlement in Ende. Independent named reference; not a surveyed farm coordinate.","method":"Published named point; no polygon-derived centroid or nearest-border snap."},{"id":"ethiopia-72","atlasRegionId":"ethiopia-72","atlasName":"Gimbi","originalCoordinates":[36.52,9.17],"proposedCoordinates":[35.833333,9.166667],"referenceLabel":"Gimbi district and town · administrative references (2020)","pointEvidence":{"sourceId":"nga-ETH","ufi":"-611615","uni":null,"type":"published-named-place","name":"Gīmbī","designation":"PPL","evidenceIds":["nga-names","gimbi-town-study","gimbi-research"],"records":[{"ufi":"-611615","uni":"-863614","full_name":"Gīmbī","nt":"N","lat_dd":"9.166667","long_dd":"35.833333","desig_cd":"PPL","adm1":"ET-OR","mod_dt_ft":"2024-12-17T13:50:33.000Z","mod_dt_nm":"1993-09-01T00:00:00.000Z"}]},"status":"ready","limitations":"Union preserves both separately encoded Gimbi town and surrounding Gimbi district. Representative point is the independently published town location, not a farm position or polygon centroid.","before":[36.52,9.17],"after":[35.833333,9.166667],"scope":"Union preserves both separately encoded Gimbi town and surrounding Gimbi district. Representative point is the independently published town location, not a farm position or polygon centroid.","method":"Independently published NGA or UNESCO named reference, not a computed polygon centroid or nearest-border snap."},{"id":"yemen-109","atlasRegionId":"yemen-109","atlasName":"Bani Matar","originalCoordinates":[43.66,15.28],"proposedCoordinates":[44.049783,15.178161],"referenceLabel":"Bani Matar district · administrative reference (2021)","pointEvidence":{"sourceId":"nga-YEM","ufi":"10618703","uni":"11307787","type":"published-administrative-reference","name":"Banī Maţar","designation":"ADM2","evidenceIds":["nga-names","matar-exporter"],"records":[{"ufi":"10618703","uni":"11307787","full_name":"Banī Maţar","nt":"N","lat_dd":"15.178161","long_dd":"44.049783","desig_cd":"ADM2","adm1":"YE-SN","mod_dt_ft":"2009-11-24T00:00:00.000Z","mod_dt_nm":"2009-11-23T00:00:00.000Z"}]},"status":"ready","limitations":"Named district geography; cultivated terraces occupy only part. NGA point is a published district name-reference, not a field survey.","before":[43.66,15.28],"after":[44.049783,15.178161],"scope":"Named district geography; cultivated terraces occupy only part. NGA point is a published district name-reference, not a field survey.","method":"Independently published NGA or UNESCO named reference, not a computed polygon centroid or nearest-border snap."},{"id":"yemen-110","atlasRegionId":"yemen-110","atlasName":"Bani Ismail","originalCoordinates":[43.43,14.91],"proposedCoordinates":[43.637948,15.210872],"referenceLabel":"Bani Ismail subdistrict · administrative reference (2019)","pointEvidence":{"sourceId":"nga-YEM","ufi":"11968957","uni":"14696447","type":"published-administrative-reference","name":"Banī Ismā‘īl","designation":"ADM3","evidenceIds":["nga-names","ismail-exporter"],"records":[{"ufi":"11968957","uni":"14696447","full_name":"Banī Ismā‘īl","nt":"N","lat_dd":"15.210872","long_dd":"43.637948","desig_cd":"ADM3","adm1":"YE-SN","mod_dt_ft":"2014-02-20T00:00:00.000Z","mod_dt_nm":"2014-02-24T00:00:00.000Z"}]},"status":"ready","limitations":"Exact named subdistrict in Manakhah. NGA matching ADM3 name-reference independently confirms location; not the same-name tribe’s older broad reference point or unrelated villages. Not a cultivation polygon.","before":[43.43,14.91],"after":[43.637948,15.210872],"scope":"Exact named subdistrict in Manakhah. NGA matching ADM3 name-reference independently confirms location; not the same-name tribe’s older broad reference point or unrelated villages. Not a cultivation polygon.","method":"Independently published NGA or UNESCO named reference, not a computed polygon centroid or nearest-border snap."},{"id":"yemen-111","atlasRegionId":"yemen-111","atlasName":"Razih","originalCoordinates":[43.42,17.19],"proposedCoordinates":[43.260801,16.937041],"referenceLabel":"Razih district · administrative reference (2021)","pointEvidence":{"sourceId":"nga-YEM","ufi":"-3191055","uni":"11308101","type":"published-administrative-reference","name":"Rāziḩ","designation":"ADM2","evidenceIds":["nga-names"],"records":[{"ufi":"-3191055","uni":"11308101","full_name":"Rāziḩ","nt":"N","lat_dd":"16.937041","long_dd":"43.260801","desig_cd":"ADM2","adm1":"YE-SD","mod_dt_ft":"2009-11-24T00:00:00.000Z","mod_dt_nm":"2009-11-23T00:00:00.000Z"}]},"status":"ready","limitations":"Named district reference, not all Khawlani coffee territory. Corrected reference is NGA’s district label coordinate in Saada, rather than the old Majz location.","before":[43.42,17.19],"after":[43.260801,16.937041],"scope":"Named district reference, not all Khawlani coffee territory. Corrected reference is NGA’s district label coordinate in Saada, rather than the old Majz location.","method":"Independently published NGA or UNESCO named reference, not a computed polygon centroid or nearest-border snap."},{"id":"yemen-112","atlasRegionId":"yemen-112","atlasName":"Bura","originalCoordinates":[43.37,15.2],"proposedCoordinates":[43.416667,14.916667],"referenceLabel":"Bura district · administrative reference (2021)","pointEvidence":{"sourceId":"bura-unesco","type":"published-mountain-region-reference","name":"Jabal Bura","rawCoordinate":"14°55′N 43°25′E","evidenceIds":["bura-unesco"]},"status":"ready","limitations":"District reference around Jabal Bura. This is not the UNESCO tentative-list property or biosphere reserve boundary.","before":[43.37,15.2],"after":[43.416667,14.916667],"scope":"District reference around Jabal Bura. This is not the UNESCO tentative-list property or biosphere reserve boundary.","method":"Independently published NGA or UNESCO named reference, not a computed polygon centroid or nearest-border snap."},{"id":"yemen-114","atlasRegionId":"yemen-114","atlasName":"Khawlan","originalCoordinates":[44.37,15.33],"proposedCoordinates":[44.702496,15.270134],"referenceLabel":"Khawlan district, Sanaa · named administrative component (2021)","pointEvidence":{"sourceId":"nga-YEM","ufi":"-3188759","uni":"11308159","type":"published-administrative-reference","name":"Khawlān","designation":"ADM2","evidenceIds":["nga-names","khawlan-nic","khawlan-photo"],"records":[{"ufi":"-3188759","uni":"11308159","full_name":"Khawlān","nt":"N","lat_dd":"15.270134","long_dd":"44.702496","desig_cd":"ADM2","adm1":"YE-SN","mod_dt_ft":"2009-11-24T00:00:00.000Z","mod_dt_nm":"2009-11-23T00:00:00.000Z"}]},"status":"ready","limitations":"Display as Khawlan (Sanaa). Existing Jabal al-Lawz photo plus NIC geography identifies the broader Khawlan al-Tiyal branch in Sanaa, not Khawlan Amer in Saada. This current district is one administrative component of that broader region. NGA district point is an explicit administrative reference, not the photo location or a coffee farm. Remove unsupported distinct coffee-region/cup claims; no verified cultivation extent is supplied.","before":[44.37,15.33],"after":[44.702496,15.270134],"scope":"Display as Khawlan (Sanaa). Existing Jabal al-Lawz photo plus NIC geography identifies the broader Khawlan al-Tiyal branch in Sanaa, not Khawlan Amer in Saada. This current district is one administrative component of that broader region. NGA district point is an explicit administrative reference, not the photo location or a coffee farm. Remove unsupported distinct coffee-region/cup claims; no verified cultivation extent is supplied.","method":"Independently published NGA or UNESCO named reference, not a computed polygon centroid or nearest-border snap."},{"id":"yemen-116","atlasRegionId":"yemen-116","atlasName":"Hayma","originalCoordinates":[45.2,15.85],"proposedCoordinates":[43.863731,15.287397],"referenceLabel":"Hayma · inner and outer district references (2021)","pointEvidence":{"sourceId":"nga-YEM","ufi":"10618698","uni":"11307782","type":"published-administrative-reference","name":"Al Ḩaymah ad Dākhlīyah","designation":"ADM2","evidenceIds":["nga-names","yemen-genetics"],"records":[{"ufi":"10618698","uni":"11307782","full_name":"Al Ḩaymah ad Dākhlīyah","nt":"N","lat_dd":"15.287397","long_dd":"43.863731","desig_cd":"ADM2","adm1":"YE-SN","mod_dt_ft":"2009-11-24T00:00:00.000Z","mod_dt_nm":"2009-11-23T00:00:00.000Z"}]},"status":"ready","limitations":"Union of the two named coffee regions in original field research. Proposed representative point is independently published NGA Al Haymah ad Dakhliyah reference; it is intentionally within one component, not the union centroid.","before":[45.2,15.85],"after":[43.863731,15.287397],"scope":"Union of the two named coffee regions in original field research. Proposed representative point is independently published NGA Al Haymah ad Dakhliyah reference; it is intentionally within one component, not the union centroid.","method":"Independently published NGA or UNESCO named reference, not a computed polygon centroid or nearest-border snap."},{"id":"brazil-3","regionId":"brazil-3","catalogName":"Matas de Minas","oldCoordinates":[-42.5,-19],"proposedCoordinates":[-42.03371548,-20.25718965],"pointLabel":"Manhuaçu — representative city within the documented region","pointType":"named municipal-seat reference, not regional centroid","sourceFeatureId":"BC250_2025_lml_cidade_p.38978","municipalityCode":"3139409","sourceDataset":"IBGE BC250_2025_lml_cidade_p","sourceYear":2025,"sourceFile":"ibge-cities-selected.geojson","sourceFileSha256":"49c515e5d5afd2dc735aaf58c44e93c914fa41c6ea2c830b14976882bca69711","sourceUrl":"https://geoservicos.ibge.gov.br/geoserver/wfs?service=WFS&version=2.0.0&request=GetFeature&typeNames=CCAR%3ABC250_2025_lml_cidade_p&outputFormat=application%2Fjson&srsName=EPSG%3A4326&cql_filter=nome+IN+%28%27Manhua%C3%A7u%27%2C%27Vit%C3%B3ria+da+Conquista%27%29","independentSourceGeometry":true,"derivedFromPolygon":false,"containsProposedPoint":true,"membershipEvidence":["https://www.gov.br/inpi/pt-br/servicos/indicacoes-geograficas/arquivos/certificados-de-ig/br402018000002-7_matas_de_minas_certificado_assinado.pdf"],"applied":false,"interpretation":"Optional explicitly named regional reference marker for this scoped outline; not proof that the original broad coffee-region point is wrong, and not a regional centroid.","before":[-42.5,-19],"after":[-42.03371548,-20.25718965],"scope":"Manhuaçu — representative city within the documented region. Named regional reference; not a farm coordinate or production centroid.","method":"Independent published named-place coordinates; no coordinate derived from the displayed polygon."},{"id":"brazil-6","regionId":"brazil-6","catalogName":"Planalto Bahia","oldCoordinates":[-41.5,-14.5],"proposedCoordinates":[-40.84524544,-14.85507407],"pointLabel":"Vitória da Conquista — representative city within the documented region","pointType":"named municipal-seat reference, not regional centroid","sourceFeatureId":"BC250_2025_lml_cidade_p.32830","municipalityCode":"2933307","sourceDataset":"IBGE BC250_2025_lml_cidade_p","sourceYear":2025,"sourceFile":"ibge-cities-selected.geojson","sourceFileSha256":"49c515e5d5afd2dc735aaf58c44e93c914fa41c6ea2c830b14976882bca69711","sourceUrl":"https://geoservicos.ibge.gov.br/geoserver/wfs?service=WFS&version=2.0.0&request=GetFeature&typeNames=CCAR%3ABC250_2025_lml_cidade_p&outputFormat=application%2Fjson&srsName=EPSG%3A4326&cql_filter=nome+IN+%28%27Manhua%C3%A7u%27%2C%27Vit%C3%B3ria+da+Conquista%27%29","independentSourceGeometry":true,"derivedFromPolygon":false,"containsProposedPoint":true,"membershipEvidence":["https://www.fapesb.ba.gov.br/seminario-de-ig-dos-cafes-do-planalto-de-vitoria-da-conquista-tem-apoio-da-fapesb/"],"applied":false,"interpretation":"Optional explicitly named regional reference marker for this scoped outline; not proof that the original broad coffee-region point is wrong, and not a regional centroid.","before":[-41.5,-14.5],"after":[-40.84524544,-14.85507407],"scope":"Vitória da Conquista — representative city within the documented region. Named regional reference; not a farm coordinate or production centroid.","method":"Independent published named-place coordinates; no coordinate derived from the displayed polygon."},{"id":"honduras-33","regionId":"honduras-33","catalogName":"Opalaca","oldCoordinates":[-88.5,14.8],"proposedCoordinates":[-88.36667,14.5],"pointLabel":"Cordillera de Opalaca — gazetteer mountain-range reference","pointType":"MTS","sourceRecord":{"geonameid":"3604215","name":"Cordillera de Opalaca","asciiname":"Cordillera de Opalaca","alternatenames":"Cerro de Poca,Cerros de Opalaca,Cordillera de Opalaca,Ramal de Opalaca,Sierra Opalaca","latitude":"14.5","longitude":"-88.36667","featureClass":"T","featureCode":"MTS","countryCode":"HN","cc2":"","admin1Code":"00","admin2Code":"","admin3Code":"","admin4Code":"","population":"0","elevation":"","dem":"1915","timezone":"America/Tegucigalpa","modificationDate":"2012-01-18"},"sourceUrl":"https://www.geonames.org/3604215","downloadUrl":"https://download.geonames.org/export/dump/HN.zip","dumpSha256":"91360eca3f51bab060f2ae3cc5225d72ff87cc634f8c96dd37ef42878beb1082","sourceFile":"geonames-points-selected.json","license":"CC BY 4.0","licenseUrl":"https://www.geonames.org/about.html","independentSourceGeometry":true,"derivedFromPolygon":false,"containsProposedPoint":true,"membershipEvidence":["https://www.earthenv.org/mountains","https://doi.org/10.48601/earthenv-t9k2-1407","https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-022-01256-y"],"applied":false,"interpretation":"Optional explicitly named regional reference marker for this scoped outline; not proof that the original broad coffee-region point is wrong, and not a regional centroid.","before":[-88.5,14.8],"after":[-88.36667,14.5],"scope":"Cordillera de Opalaca — gazetteer mountain-range reference. Named regional reference; not a farm coordinate or production centroid.","method":"Independent published named-place coordinates; no coordinate derived from the displayed polygon."},{"id":"guatemala-37","regionId":"guatemala-37","catalogName":"Atitlán","oldCoordinates":[-91.19,14.7],"proposedCoordinates":[-91.28666,14.69453],"pointLabel":"San Juan La Laguna — town participating in the Atitlán coffee route","pointType":"PPLA2","sourceRecord":{"geonameid":"3589896","name":"San Juan La Laguna","asciiname":"San Juan La Laguna","alternatenames":"San Juan,San Juan La Laguna","latitude":"14.69453","longitude":"-91.28666","featureClass":"P","featureCode":"PPLA2","countryCode":"GT","cc2":"","admin1Code":"19","admin2Code":"","admin3Code":"","admin4Code":"","population":"4608","elevation":"","dem":"1605","timezone":"America/Guatemala","modificationDate":"2019-01-09"},"sourceUrl":"https://www.geonames.org/3589896","downloadUrl":"https://download.geonames.org/export/dump/GT.zip","dumpSha256":"062bfba0e783bb676e4c96b80c4eb401697d7f155e63991ff2235bc7d0d04ed1","sourceFile":"geonames-points-selected.json","license":"CC BY 4.0","licenseUrl":"https://www.geonames.org/about.html","independentSourceGeometry":true,"derivedFromPolygon":false,"containsProposedPoint":true,"membershipEvidence":["https://www.anacafe.org/noticias/ruta-ecologica/"],"applied":false,"interpretation":"Optional explicitly named regional reference marker for this scoped outline; not proof that the original broad coffee-region point is wrong, and not a regional centroid.","before":[-91.19,14.7],"after":[-91.28666,14.69453],"scope":"San Juan La Laguna — town participating in the Atitlán coffee route. Named regional reference; not a farm coordinate or production centroid.","method":"Independent published named-place coordinates; no coordinate derived from the displayed polygon."},{"id":"costa-rica-63","regionId":"costa-rica-63","catalogName":"Tres Ríos","oldCoordinates":[-83.97,9.88],"proposedCoordinates":[-83.98789,9.90692],"pointLabel":"Tres Ríos — town in La Unión canton","pointType":"PPL","sourceRecord":{"geonameid":"3621224","name":"Tres Ríos","asciiname":"Tres Rios","alternatenames":"La Union,La Unión,Tres Rios,Tres Ríos","latitude":"9.90692","longitude":"-83.98789","featureClass":"P","featureCode":"PPL","countryCode":"CR","cc2":"","admin1Code":"02","admin2Code":"303","admin3Code":"30301","admin4Code":"","population":"10430","elevation":"","dem":"1332","timezone":"America/Costa_Rica","modificationDate":"2022-02-17"},"sourceUrl":"https://www.geonames.org/3621224","downloadUrl":"https://download.geonames.org/export/dump/CR.zip","dumpSha256":"ed42565b78a47a95cc286a5c53e78a7bce5019bcc5106730a985ef69b7180e35","sourceFile":"geonames-points-selected.json","license":"CC BY 4.0","licenseUrl":"https://www.geonames.org/about.html","independentSourceGeometry":true,"derivedFromPolygon":false,"containsProposedPoint":true,"membershipEvidence":["https://launion.go.cr/sobre-la-union/","https://www.sinabi.go.cr/biblioteca%20digital/revistas/revista%20del%20instituto%20de%20defensa%20del%20cafe/revista%20del%20instituto%20de%20defensa%20del%20cafe%201936/b-Rev%20Instituto%20de%20Defensa%20del%20Cafe.pdf"],"applied":false,"interpretation":"Optional explicitly named regional reference marker for this scoped outline; not proof that the original broad coffee-region point is wrong, and not a regional centroid.","before":[-83.97,9.88],"after":[-83.98789,9.90692],"scope":"Tres Ríos — town in La Unión canton. Named regional reference; not a farm coordinate or production centroid.","method":"Independent published named-place coordinates; no coordinate derived from the displayed polygon."}]}